Methodology

How we review and score LLC services

Every provider goes through the same five steps and is scored on the same five criteria. This page sets out each one, so you can judge our rankings for yourself.

  • Same criteria for every provider
  • Cost counted over two years
  • Commission is not a criterion
Step 1

We choose which providers to cover

We cover a service when a reader is likely to be weighing it up. That means it forms LLCs in all 50 states, sells directly to the public online and publishes its prices.

Whether a provider has an affiliate programme plays no part in this choice. Services that pay us nothing are reviewed alongside those that do.

Step 2

We walk through the checkout

The advertised price and the price at the payment screen are often different. So we go through each provider's order flow for the same test case: a single-member LLC on the entry plan.

What we record

  • The formation fee shown at the start and the total shown at the end
  • Every add-on offered along the way, and its price
  • Whether any add-on is selected for you by default
  • Which items renew automatically, and at what price
  • How the state filing fee is shown: separately, or folded into a total
Step 3

We add up the cost over two years

A registered agent is the person or company that receives legal mail for your LLC, and every state requires one. Many services include the agent free for a year and then renew it at $100 to $300. That renewal is where most of the real cost sits.

So the number we compare is the two-year total: the formation fee, plus the registered agent in year one, plus the first renewal. The state filing fee is left out, because it is the same whichever service you use.

A worked example

Provider A charges $0 to form and $199 a year for the agent: $398 over two years. Provider B charges $39 to form, includes the agent in year one and renews it at $125: $164 over two years. The "$0" plan costs more than twice as much.

Step 4

We score five criteria

Each criterion is scored from 1 to 5. The overall score is the weighted average, shown to one decimal place.

Criterion Weight What we look at What scores well
Total cost over two years 30% Formation fee, registered agent and first renewal, added together. A low two-year total, with no surprise at renewal.
Registered agent terms 20% Renewal price, whose address appears on the public filing, and how you cancel. A stable price, the provider's address on the record, and cancellation online.
Filing speed 20% How long the provider says it holds an order before sending it to the state, on the entry plan. Orders sent to the state within one business day, without paying for a faster tier.
Checkout clarity 15% The number of add-ons offered, and whether any are selected by default. Few add-ons, none pre-selected, and a clear total before payment.
Support 15% Which contact channels exist, when they are open, and how a standard question is answered. A person who answers the question asked, without a sales pitch.
Step 5

We rank, and name one top pick

Rankings follow the overall scores, highest first. The provider in first place is our top pick. If two providers tie, the one with the lower two-year cost goes first.

A single ranking cannot suit everyone, so each provider also gets a "best for" line: the kind of owner it fits. Someone who will act as their own registered agent should weigh the list differently from someone who wants their home address kept off the public record.

When a provider changes its prices or plans, we re-check the figures and update the score. If you see a number that is out of date, tell us.

What never changes a score

  • Whether a provider pays us a commission, or how much
  • A provider asking for a higher rank or the removal of a con
  • How large or well known the brand is
  • Star ratings on third-party review sites

The limits of this method

  • State processing times are outside any provider's control and change through the year
  • Prices can change between our check and your visit, so confirm the total at checkout
  • Our test case is a single-member LLC; a multi-member or foreign LLC may cost more
  • A score is a summary, not legal or tax advice for your situation